US & Israel’s Nuclear Secrets

01/28/2013

Abby Martin talks to Grant Smith, Director of the Institute for Research: Middle Eastern Policy, about NUMEC, Israel’s nuclear ambiguity and nuclear secrets.

 

The Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation (NUMEC) and the Diversion of US Government Weapons-Grade Uranium to Israel

Since the mid-1960s law enforcement and regulatory agencies suspected a small nuclear processing facility in Pennsylvania had illegally diverted U.S. government-owned weapons-grade nuclear material into Israel’s clandestine nuclear weapons program.  The Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation received start-up capital organized by a mysterious former smuggler with deep and ongoing ties to Israeli intelligence.  FBI investigations revealed NUMEC President Zalman Mordecai Shapiro also had repeated unexplained interactions with Israeli intelligence and organized a joint venture with the primary front organization of the Israeli nuclear weapons program.  According to a 2001 US Department of Energy report, NUMEC still holds the record for the highest losses of bomb-grade material of any plant in the United States. 

In April 1976 Attorney General Edward Levi ordered the FBI to reopen an investigation into Dr. Zalman Shapiro and the Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation (NUMEC). The newly reopened investigation looked beyond violations of the Atomic Energy Act. The FBI’s new mandate was to also uncover “any attempt by anyone in the executive branch to prevent or impede an investigation into this alleged diversion, or to withhold any information regarding this alleged diversion from any investigative body.” The FBI code-named its investigation “DIVERT.” The FBI interrogated high-level officials from U.S. government agencies and NUMEC employee eyewitnesses to nuclear diversion.  Inexplicably, on January 23, 1981 the FBI placed the NUMEC investigation into “closed status” until further instructions from the Department of Justice.  Field offices were ordered not to destroy files without instructions from FBI headquarters.  The NUMEC investigation portfolio, which had passed from LBJ, to Nixon, and on to Ford was closed at the end of the Carter administration.

Document/PDF	Contents
Articles of Incorporation Commonwealth of Pennsylvania 490 KB, 8 pages	NUMEC is incorporated on December 31, 1956 in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania by Zalman M. Shapiro (Nautilus nuclear submarine program chemist, Zionist Organization of America Pennsylvania chapter president), Leonard Pepkowtiz (Manhattan Project weapons physicist) and Frederick Foerscher.
Articles of Merger Commonwealth of Pennsylvania 219 KB, 25 pages	Apollo Industries holding company created on March 1, 1958 out of merger of three defunct companies: Apollo Steel Company, American Nut and Bolt Fastener Company and San Toy Mining Company.  Apollo Industry directors included Ivan J. Novick (future ZOA president) ,David Lowenthal (refugee smuggler who also fought in Israel), Zalman Shapiro (NUMEC president, ZOA chapter president), and Elliott W. Finkel (former DOJ attorney dismissed over conflicts of interest).
NUMEC_1966 Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation 6.1 MB, 62 pages	Company calendar listing NUMEC’s services.
11031966_AEC_FBI_NUMEC_Activity.pdf	John Vinciguerra of the Atomic Energy Agency provides a list of all NUMEC contracts with foreign governments as part of a Foreign Agent Registration Act and congressional review.
071967_Atantic_Richfield Hanford 135 KB, 2 pages	The Atomic Energy Commission gives Atlantic Richfield at $30 million/year contract to manage Hanford facilities if it buys and takes over NUMEC. Pages extracted from cost-plus operating contract.
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 1 FBI 2.2 MB,  45 pages	Section 1 – Zalman Shapiro investigated by the FBI for potential Foreign Agents Registration Act after 61 kilograms of U-235 are discovered missing from the Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation.  FBI establishes surveillance of Shapiro in 1968.  Nature of David Lowenthal’s relationship and financing of NUMEC discovered. David Lowenthal observed in photos “shaking hands with Ben-Gurion and Moshe Dayan” and “reportedly fought for Israel as a freedom fighter in 1956 and travels to Israel on the average of approximately once per month.” NUMEC’s founders, security clearances, shipment of 320 grams of plutonium to Israel  in 1963, censored files.
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 2 FBI 728 KB, 11 pages	On September 6, 1968, the US attorney general requests investigation “whether the subject is acting as an agent of the Israeli Government.”  September 6, 1968 NUMEC request for visit of Avraham Hermoni (Israeli nuclear weapons chief), Ephraim Biegun, Avraham Bendor, and Rafael Eitan (founder of LAKAM economic espionage network).  The intelligence operatives enter under the cover of being “thermo electric generator specialists.”
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 3 FBI 35 KB,  1 page	Censored content.
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 1 (830179) FBI 3.2 MB, 56 pages	FBI initiates physical and wiretap surveillance of Zalman Shapiro on November 5, 1968.  “We are investigating Shapiro to determine extent of his relations with Israeli government.  As head of Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation, Apollo, Pennsylvania, which processes uranium-235 for nuclear reactors, Shapiro has access to atomic energy material which could be most helpful to the Israelis…subject has been in contact on two occasions with Dr. Avraham Hermoni, Scientific Counselor, Israeli Embassy, Washington D.C., and Israeli intelligence agent.  Source has also disclosed contacts with a senior official of Israeli military intelligence, individuals associated with Israeli Atomic Energy Commission and member of Israeli Internal Security Service…he is considering settling permanently in that country and, if necessary, would fight for Israel…”  “Investigation has further disclosed that subject and others involved in instant case, in addition to holding top positions in their respective fields, are very active and highly regarded in various Jewish organizations which exert some influence in this country….” “It is considered opinion of person familiar with this case that an interview with subject and/or others intimately involved in this case would develop very little pertinent information…”  “Attorney General under date of 3/28/1969 approved our request for continuation of Electronic Surveillance for a period of three months effective 4/1/1969. Wiretap summaries. Atomic Energy Commission interview of Shapiro on August 14, 1969.  Discussion of 1968 Hermoni meeting in Shapiro’s home, clandestine Shapiro meeting with Israeli intelligence agent in Pittsburgh airport. “Only when we confronted with the fact that we were aware of the meeting did he admit to such a meeting had taken place and his explanation that the purpose of the meeting had been to discuss payment of a bill and other commercial matters did not appear to be completely candid…”
Wiretap FBI 362 KB,  11 pages	May 5, 1969 FBI wiretap of a radioactive spill at NUMEC caused by improper storage.  “9:18 p.m.: CENSORED reported on a spillage at the plant. They have the area roped off and it will take some pick and shovel work to dig up the contaminated areas. CENSORED said they are getting 100,000 counts. CENSORED said, “Oh, God.” They are dampening it down to avoid dust and will cover it if it looks like it may rain. CENSORED asked if there is anything on AAI? …  9:20 p.m.: CENSORED said that he heard that American Instrument Company [is] up for sale. He said he heard this from the former sales manager.” A phone call placed just two minutes after the first confirms that: “it’s not only a bad spill but “actually they are operating outside compliance.” They had the drums all together. They have about 200 drums and estimate that about six a day will corrode through. The trouble lay with a fluoride which was put in to help the decay, and this was not checked. CENSORED said they are also about $230,000 over on their construction costs for the scrap plant. Z [Zalman Shapiro] said if they could get other people, there would be a lot of firing.”
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 4 FBI 6.3 MB, 95 pages	January 20, 1969 FBI report on Shapiro meetings with Hermoni to coordinate a plutonium purchase, Shapiro requests to AEC about availability of plutonium (does not mention Israel as destination). AEC Commission Glenn Seaborg approves sales “Criticality is the only concern in terms of the amount of plutonium 238 that can be used in any particular device.”  Details of NUMEC trying to obtain US government equipment for free by falsely claiming it is contaminated. Zalman Shapiro discusses settling in Israel.  NUMEC discovered to be an agent of the Israeli Ministry of Defense, and have a joint venture with the Israeli Atomic Energy Commission, the cover organization for Israel’s nuclear weapons program.  Shapiro concerned US will not sell fighter jets to Israel.  FBI source speculates that U-235 could have been shipped to Israel within food irradiator units with “no questions asked.” NUMEC catalog of irradiators. In February of 1969, FBI reviews NUMEC’s classified contracts with the US government.  NUMEC attempts to hire AEC or “other government agencies” employees.  Secret Service warned on February 18, 1969 that Shapiro “under active investigation as member of other group or organization inimical to the U.S.” February 16, 1968 report of Shapiro hosting a meeting in his home “with Avraham Hermoni, Scientific Counselor, Israeli Embassy, and ten other men who have special skills and knowledge  in scientific and technical fields on 11/4/1968. This meeting was held to assist Hermoni in gathering necessary data in these areas for Israel.” Shapiro discusses obtaining plutonium 238 with Colonel Avraham Eylonie. Shapiro meets with Israeli defense minister at the Israeli embassy on November 26, 1969 before leaving for Israel between November 28 and December 12, 1968. Profiles of NUMEC executives.  Summary of 1965 Foreign Agents Registration Act investigation of Shapiro.  June 21, 1966 FBI interview of Shapiro.  NUMEC employee interviews
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 5 FBI 3.1 MB, 39 pages	Zalman Shapiro listed in “Security Index” because he “continues to solicit information of Israeli scientific [censored] personnel.”   NUMEC selected in 1964 to run “free world’s only full-scale production boron isotope facility” in Niagara [Lewiston], NY.   Shapiro assisting in a secret converter “British Project.” Supermarket advertiser Frank Noll writes “Dr. X” story about Shapiro working in Israeli nuclear weapons program.
07191969 Nixon Presidential Library 973 KB, 18 pages	July, 1969 Henry Kissinger strategy document about what stance to take about the Israeli nuclear weapons program.  “There is circumstantial evidence that some fissionable material available for Israel’s weapons development was illegally obtained from the United States by about 1965.”  Justification for “ambiguity” stance.
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 6 FBI 1 MB, 26 pages	Illegible files.  September 3, 1969 FBI director memo to AEC and DOJ about August 1969 AEC interview of Zalman Shapiro. “The basis of the security risk posed by the subject lies in his continuing access to sensitive information and material and it is believed that the effective way to counter this risk would be to preclude Shapiro from such access, specifically by terminating his classified contracts and lifting his security clearances.  AEC security statement that Shapiro has “knowingly established an association with individuals reliably reported as suspected of espionage.”  “It was reported in 1961 that Dr. Abraham Hermoni was a member of the Israeli Intelligence Service; that in 1963 Dr. Hermoni was known to be engaged in the establishment of a technical intelligence network in the United States, and that prior to his assignment as Scientific Counselor of the Israeli Embassy, Washington, D.C. he was intimately connected with Israeli efforts to develop nuclear weapons in his capacity as Technical Director, Armament Development Authority, Ministry of Defense.” On November 4, 1970, the FBI notes that Shapiro has taken a job at Kawecki Berylco Industries, and “holds a ‘Secret’ clearance which was transferred to that facility by the Defense Supply Agency…”  Note “Shapiro has been alleged to have furnished information to Israeli Government in the past regarding nuclear developments via Israeli Embassy officials interested in this field for the benefit of Israeli defense efforts.  He is carried on the Security Index by Pittsburgh due to his activities.  He has recently acquired a new and sensitive position with a nuclear development company in Pennsylvania…classified ‘Secret’ since it sets forth information from [censored] Army communications similarly classified.”
09031969 Gerald Ford Presidential Library 332 KB, 6 pages	September 3, 1969 FBI Director memo to CIA Director.  “The basis of the security risk posed by the subject lies in his continuing access to sensitive information and material and it is believed the only effective way to counter this risk would be to preclude Shapiro from access, specifically by terminating his classified contracts and lifting his security clearances…”
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 7 FBI 5.9 MB,  136 pages	FBI interviews Kanwecki Berylco Industry executive on March 4, 1971 about Zalman Shapiro’s attempts to obtain classified information  without proper security clearance. Joint Committee on Atomic Energy attempts to obtain FBI files “concerning Shapiro or any of his associates or acquaintances who could be involved in intelligence or diversion of nuclear material activities on behalf of a foreign government.” in May of 1976.  FBI offers a summary, but states that attorney general would have to approve file release.  April 22, 1976 summary of FBI investigations of NUMEC for special nuclear materials loss.  On May 14, 1976 US attorney general orders an FBI investigation “be conducted to determine whether or not a diversion of nuclear material had occurred at the Nuclear Materials and Equipment Corporation (NUMEC), Apollo, Pennsylvania, partially owned and operated by the subject, and if this diversion had been to the benefit of the Government of Israel” and “Obstruction of Justice.”  Attorney General provides list of Atomic Energy Commission executives to interview.  Fully and partially censored FBI interview records.  1976 investigation captioned “DIVERT.”  List of NUMEC executives to interview.
12071977 Jimmy Carter Presidential Library 146 KB, 2 pages	December 7, 1977 Memo to Zbigniew Brezinski about Congressional investigation of NUMEC.  “Dingell’s pursuit of the question of whether the CIA withheld information from other agencies strikes me as potentially dangerous…“
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 8 FBI 625 KB, 8 pages	June 27, 1977 FBI interview of Zalman Shapiro.  “..Shapiro voiced certain reservations relative to its purpose and was concerned that display of the form implied certain unlawful acts on his part.”  “Shapiro emphasized that the matter of significant diversion of special nuclear material at NUMEC was out of the question and added that Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) officials had, in fact, assured him personally that NUMEC MUF compared favorably with MUF experienced throughout the rest of the industry.”
021978 Inquiry into the Testimony of the Executive Director for Operations Nuclear Regulatory Commission Page accidently released to NRDC 3.5 MB, 3 pages	Classified summary of CIA Directorate of Operations briefing to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission about NUMEC diversion accidentally released to the Natural Resources Defense Council.  “Mr. Duckett raised the question of whether the U.S. had intentiona1ly allowed material to go to Israel. He said that if any such scheme was under consideration, he would have known about it and he never heard so much as a rumor about this.  He, therefore, does not believe there is any substance to this allegation. In support of this view, he related that CIA had drafted a National Intelligence Estimate on Israel’s nuclear capability in 1968.  It it was the conclusion that the Israelis had nuclear weapons.  He showed it to Mr. Helms.  Helms told him not to publish it and he would take it up with President Johnson.  Mr. Helms later related that he had spoken to the president, that the President was concerned, and that he had said, ‘Don’t tell anyone else, even Dean Rusk and Robert McNamara.”
06211978 Glenn T. Seaborg Papers Library of Congress 482 KB, 1 page	Glenn Seaborg office diary.  On June 21, 1978 Department of Energy investigators Bill Knauf and Jim Anderson visit former Atomic Energy Commissioner Glenn T. Seaborg.  They tell Seaborg that traces of Portsmouth U-235 (the government-owned material primarily delivered to NUMEC for processing into fuel) had been picked up in Israel.  On March 3, 1979 Seaborg refuses to be interviewed by FBI investigators.
Archive	A 1978 General Accounting Office study concludes that the US government never credibly investigated the NUMEC diversion and documents FBI and CIA refusal to cooperate..
12121978 Morris K. Udall Papers at the University of Arizona 4.2 MB, 119 pages	Transcript of December 21, 1978 Congressional Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs interview of Zalman Shapiro. “We know now that as far back as 1966, at least one staff member of the Joint Committee on Atomic Energy questioned the propriety of then AEC Chairman Seaborg having testified that he thought that ” there has not been any material diverted from peaceful to military uses.” We know also that in December 1971, William Riley, former director of AEC security, wrote in a memorandum that Dr. Shapiro reported to Riley that he (Dr. Shapiro) had been told by officials of the government of Israel that an unnamed AEC Commissioner had suggested to representatives of a foreign government that Dr. Shapiro had been involved in diversion of materials to the Israelis…”
02281979 Jimmy Carter Presidential Library 145 KB, 3 pages	Confidential letter from Deputy Attorney General Benjamin Civiletti to President Jimmy Carter about how after the GAO report about NUMEC the US would “establish a plan for coordinated interagency action to detect and investigate the theft or diversion of nuclear material in the future.”
11271979 Jimmy Carter Presidential Library 107 KB, 2 pages	Staffer Jerry Oplinger asks National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brezinski for permission to show Senator John Glenn a top secret memorandum about “missing material from the NUMEC plant in Apollo, PA.”  Brezinski formally disapproves, telling Oplinger to “Brief him [Senator Glenn] orally.”
1091168-000-117-2564  Section 10 FBI 3.9 MB, 54 pages	March 28, 1980 interviews with NRC officials reveal a former NUMEC employee eyewitness to diversion.  FBI NUMEC truck driver interview. FBI NUMEC shipping clerk interview.  March 24, 1980 FBI Ammonator interview. “he then noticed the NUMEC owner, Dr. Zalman Shapiro, pacing around the loading dock while [censored] (shipping and receiving foreman) and [censored] (truck driver for NUMEC) were loading ‘stove pipes’ into the steel cabinet type equipment that he observed on the truck…the ‘stove pipes’ are cylindrical storage containers used to store canisters of high enriched materials in the vaults located at the Apollo nuclear facility…the ‘stove pipes’ contained three or four canisters which were described as highly polished aluminum with standard printed square yellow labels, approximately three inches in diameter by six inches tall, that normally were used to store high enriched uranium products…defined as 95 percent uranium.” January 15, 1981 former NUMEC employee interview.
Archive	Zalman Shapiro seeks exoneration from the NRC assisted by Israel’s longest registered foreign agent law firm in Washington DC with assistance from Senator Arlen Spector.  The NRC refuses to clear Shapiro or NUMEC over the U-235 losses.

Via IMEP